When you see "fragrance" or "parfum" on a label, it hides a mix of up to 3,500 chemicals - natural extracts and synthetics alike. Brands often don’t disclose these ingredients due to "trade secret" protections, leaving consumers unaware of potential allergens or harmful compounds. Both natural and synthetic ingredients have pros and cons: natural ones can be allergenic and resource-intensive, while synthetics offer consistency and sustainability but often lack transparency.
Key takeaways:
Health Risks: Natural ingredients like oakmoss and jasmine can trigger allergies; synthetics may include hormone disruptors like phthalates.
Sustainability: Synthetics reduce overharvesting (e.g., sandalwood) but rely on lab processes.
Regulations: The EU requires allergen disclosure, unlike the U.S., where "fragrance" conceals specifics.
Testing Matters: Patch testing is crucial for avoiding sensitivities.
Brands like Henry Rose and EWG VERIFIED® are pushing for clearer labeling, while sampling services like Scento let you test fragrances before investing. Transparency is growing, but consumers must remain informed to make safer, smarter choices.
Natural vs Synthetic Fragrance Ingredients: Safety, Transparency, and Environmental Impact Comparison
✨ Natural vs. Synthetic Fragrance – What’s the Truth? ✨
What Are Natural and Synthetic Fragrance Ingredients?
The difference between natural and synthetic fragrance ingredients lies in their origins and how they are created. Natural ingredients come directly from nature - think flower petals, citrus peels, woods, and resins. Historically, animal-derived materials were also used, but ethical alternatives have largely replaced them today. These natural components are extracted using processes like steam distillation, cold pressing, or solvent extraction. For example, producing just one pound of rose essential oil requires over 10,000 pounds of petals, which explains its steep price - often exceeding $250 per ounce. Let’s take a closer look at both natural and synthetic ingredients.
Natural Fragrance Ingredients
Defined by ISO 9235, natural fragrance ingredients are derived from plants and other natural sources. Common extraction methods include:
Steam distillation: Steam is used to extract volatile compounds from flowers like lavender or rose.
Cold pressing: This method involves mechanically pressing citrus peels to release their oils.
Solvent extraction: Solvents like hexane are used to capture delicate scents from flowers such as jasmine or tuberose.
The 2025 IFRA Transparency List identifies 1,021 Natural Complex Substances (NCSs) currently in use within the fragrance industry. What sets natural ingredients apart is their molecular complexity. For instance, natural rose oil contains over 300 compounds, giving it a "three-dimensional" scent profile that evolves as it interacts with the skin.
Synthetic Fragrance Ingredients
Synthetic ingredients are created in laboratories through chemical synthesis or molecular engineering. These can replicate natural scents - like synthetic linalool, which mimics a naturally occurring compound - or introduce entirely new fragrances that don’t exist in nature. Some modern synthetics are even produced using yeast fermentation, which converts renewable carbon sources into fragrance molecules, reducing reliance on petroleum. This method ensures consistent quality and stability, so every bottle of perfume smells the same over time.
Master perfumer Jean — Claude Ellena describes the creative possibilities synthetics bring to perfumery:
"As a perfumer, I like showing and convincing… I am simply following the trajectory of an artist - someone who seeks and, sometimes, finds".
Why Most Fragrances Combine Natural and Synthetic Ingredients
Today’s perfumes often combine natural and synthetic components to balance their unique qualities. Natural ingredients add depth and complexity, often referred to as the "soul" of a fragrance. On the other hand, synthetics contribute structure, enhance longevity, and allow for the creation of scents that would be impractical - or even unethical - to source naturally. Additionally, synthetics are typically more affordable than rare natural materials like vanilla or sandalwood, making high-quality fragrances more accessible.
How Transparent Is the Fragrance Industry?
The fragrance industry operates under a veil of secrecy, often concealing the full list of chemicals in its products. While most cosmetic ingredients must be individually listed, the term "fragrance" on a label can hide a blend of numerous undisclosed chemicals. By understanding the system and its regulatory shortcomings, consumers can make more informed decisions about the fragrances they choose.
What the ‘Fragrance’ Label Conceals
When a product label lists "fragrance", "perfume", or "parfum", it’s not as straightforward as it seems. These terms serve as a legal workaround, allowing companies to mask complex mixtures that could include over 3,500 different chemicals. According to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration:
"Under U.S. regulations, fragrance and flavor ingredients can be listed simply as ‘Fragrance’ or ‘Flavor.’ ... This law is not allowed to be used to force a company to tell ‘trade secrets.’"
This protection, outlined in the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act, permits brands to keep their exact formulas under wraps. For instance, the 2025 IFRA Transparency List identifies 3,691 active ingredients used globally in fragrances, which include 3,312 fragrance components and 379 functional ingredients like stabilizers and solvents. Yet, consumers rarely see any of these specifics on packaging. Even products labeled "unscented" may include masking agents to neutralize unpleasant base odors. This lack of transparency stands in stark contrast to the growing demand for clearer labeling, setting the stage for a comparison of U.S. and EU regulations.
EU vs U.S. Fragrance Regulations
The regulatory landscape further complicates the issue of ingredient transparency, with significant differences between the European Union and the United States. In the U.S., trade secret protections are robust, and the FDA does not currently require allergen labeling for cosmetics. Although a federal law passed in December 2022 will eventually mandate the disclosure of certain fragrance allergens, these changes won’t take effect until at least 2025.
On the other hand, the EU enforces stricter regulations. Brands are required to disclose specific allergens and adhere to precautionary bans on certain ingredients. For example, Butylphenyl Methylpropional, commonly known as Lilial, was banned in EU cosmetic products in March 2022. However, it remains permitted in the U.S. and other non — EU markets. The International Fragrance Association explains:
"Butylphenyl Methylpropional (BMHCA), also known commercially as Lilial, has been banned in cosmetic products (both existing and new) in the European Union as of March 2022. ... The use of BMHCA remains permitted in markets outside the EU, subject to local regulations."
Here’s a quick look at how the U.S. and EU compare:
Feature
United States (FDA)
European Union (EU)
Primary Labeling
Allows "Fragrance" or "Parfum" to represent multiple ingredients
Uses "Parfum" but requires disclosure of specific allergens
Trade Secret Protection
Strong protections under FPLA
Limited; allergens must be disclosed
Allergen Disclosure
Not required until 2025
Mandatory for 26+ allergens
Ingredient Bans
Few bans (e.g., Lilial allowed)
Stricter bans (e.g., Lilial prohibited since 2022)
These regulatory differences influence not only consumer safety but also ethical considerations and ingredient sourcing practices.
Brands Committed to Ingredient Transparency
Despite these regulatory gaps, some brands are challenging the status quo by openly sharing their ingredient lists. One standout is Henry Rose, founded by actress Michelle Pfeiffer, which discloses every component of its fragrances. As Pfeiffer explains:
"You shouldn’t have to sacrifice quality for safety"
Similarly, Lvnea prioritizes transparency with its natural, botanical perfumes, all blended and bottled in-house in small batches.
Products with the EWG VERIFIED® mark also set a high standard for ingredient transparency. The Environmental Working Group requires brands to disclose all ingredients and meet stringent safety criteria. According to EWG:
"Products bearing the EWG VERIFIED® mark are an exception. The mark means a product is free from EWG chemicals of concern and meets our strictest standards for transparency and your health"
Meanwhile, IFRA members, responsible for approximately 80% of global fragrance production, publish a collective "Transparency List" of ingredients used across the industry. However, this list does not extend to detailed, brand-specific disclosures on product labels.
Natural Fragrances: Transparency, Safety, and Environmental Impact
Transparency Issues with Natural Fragrances
Natural fragrances often appear straightforward, but their complexity is frequently concealed. In the United States, for example, the term "natural" isn’t legally standardized for consumer products. This allows manufacturers to label products as natural even when ingredients retain only 50% of their original structure after processing. Adding to the confusion, these intricate ingredient profiles are often hidden behind the generic term "fragrance" on product labels.
The 2025 IFRA Transparency List identifies 3,691 ingredients, of which 1,021 are classified as Natural Complex Substances (NCSs). Even products marketed as natural may include undisclosed functional additives like solvents, stabilizers, antioxidants, and preservatives. When consumers ask for full ingredient disclosures, companies often cite proprietary concerns, which can erode trust and raise questions about safety. Compounding this, many natural extracts - such as oakmoss, jasmine, and ylang-ylang - contain potent allergens that are tightly regulated by IFRA due to health risks. Despite these risks, many consumers continue to associate "natural" with "safe", which isn’t always the case.
Environmental and Ethical Concerns
Natural ingredients also come with a heavy environmental and ethical footprint. Overharvesting of resources like Indian sandalwood has driven some species to the brink of extinction, prompting strict export controls. Additionally, many natural ingredients are sourced from regions that are environmentally or economically fragile. This can lead to ethical dilemmas, as land used for ingredient cultivation may compete with essential food production.
The cost disparity between natural and synthetic ingredients highlights another issue. Natural ingredients can cost 10–100 times more than synthetics, with prices reaching as much as €50 per kilogram. This reflects the intensive resources - land, water, and labor - required for their production. Overharvesting endangered species like rosewood and frankincense further threatens biodiversity and underscores the fragility of these practices.
How Natural Ingredients Perform in Fragrances
The challenges tied to natural ingredients extend to fragrance performance. Natural fragrances often fade within 1–2 hours, whereas synthetic alternatives can last anywhere from 6 to 12+ hours. Additionally, the chemical makeup of natural ingredients is highly variable, influenced by factors like weather, soil quality, and harvest timing. This means that a "natural rose" fragrance may smell slightly different from one batch to the next. While some consumers appreciate this organic variability, others may find it frustrating when trying to repurchase a favorite scent.
Understanding these performance nuances is essential for making informed choices. Brands that use natural ingredients should be upfront about these limitations, helping consumers recognize that shorter longevity and slight scent variations are inherent to natural products - not indicators of inferior quality. This transparency can bridge the gap between consumer expectations and the realities of using natural fragrances.
Your Personal Fragrance Expert Awaits
Join an exclusive community of fragrance connoisseurs. Each month, receive expertly curated selections from over 900+ brands, delivered in elegant 8ml crystal vials. Your personal fragrance journey, meticulously crafted.
Synthetic Fragrances: Transparency, Safety, and Environmental Impact
How Synthetics Enable Clearer Disclosure
Synthetic ingredients bring a unique advantage to the table when it comes to transparency. Their precise composition allows for a level of clarity that natural materials simply can’t achieve. Natural extracts are complex, often containing hundreds of molecules that are difficult to fully identify. In contrast, synthetic ingredients are precisely defined compounds, each with a unique Chemical Abstracts Service (CAS) number and chemical name. This level of specificity makes it easier to disclose exactly what’s in a fragrance, unlike broader labels such as "Rosa damascena" for rose extracts.
The numbers back this up. The 2025 IFRA Transparency List highlights 3,691 total ingredients, but only 1,021 are Natural Complex Substances (NCSs). The rest are isolated molecules or synthetic compounds that can be identified with scientific precision. For example, a synthetic rose note relies on just a few well-defined molecules, making allergen management much more straightforward. This precision not only enhances transparency but also helps address regulatory gaps in how synthetic formulas are disclosed.
When Synthetic Formulas Stay Hidden
However, even with their potential for transparency, synthetic formulas often remain undisclosed. Manufacturers frequently choose to keep their formulas secret to protect proprietary blends, a practice allowed under U.S. regulations. While synthetic molecules could be openly shared, trade secrets often take priority.
Regulations around disclosure vary across regions. In the EU, stricter rules have led to ingredient bans, such as the prohibition of Lilial, while other regions take a more lenient approach. The International Fragrance Association (IFRA) provides voluntary standards that cover around 80% of global fragrance production, but adherence to these standards is self-regulated. Interestingly, perfumers often find they have more freedom when working with synthetics like habanolide compared to natural materials, which face more stringent safety limitations.
While disclosure practices remain a challenge, synthetic ingredients also bring notable environmental advantages.
Environmental Benefits of Synthetic Ingredients
Synthetics play a key role in reducing the strain on fragile ecosystems, offering a more consistent and sustainable alternative for fragrance production. Take sandalwood, for instance. Natural Indian sandalwood trees must grow for 30 to 60 years before they can be harvested, a process that has pushed the species to the brink of extinction. Synthetic sandalwood replicates the scent without the need for long growth cycles or deforestation.
Synthetic production methods also tend to be more efficient. Alternatives to rare ingredients like sandalwood and rose oil conserve resources and significantly lower waste. Techniques such as microbial fermentation are even paving the way for vegan options, like musk, that don’t rely on traditional animal-derived sources. Kari Arienti, founder of AromaKnowledge, sums it up well:
"You are not chopping down forests; you’re not shipping hundreds of tons".
How to Make Informed Fragrance Choices
How to Read Fragrance Labels
When you pick up a bottle of perfume, you’ll often notice the terms "PARFUM" or "FRAGRANCE" on the label. These aren’t just placeholders - they’re used to keep fragrance formulas a mystery, as compositions aren’t patented. However, that single word can represent a mix of over 3,000 different chemicals, many of which remain undisclosed.
In the EU and on products from many global brands, potential allergens must be listed individually at the end of the ingredient list. So, instead of stopping at "Parfum", scan the label for specific chemical names that could cause sensitivities. For reference, the 2025 IFRA Transparency List includes 3,691 ingredients, which break down into 3,312 fragrance components and 379 functional additives like antioxidants and stabilizers.
Given the limited space on packaging, many brands now provide extended ingredient details online. These digital resources often organize ingredients by scent family (like floral, fruity, or woody) and their origin (natural or synthetic). You can also find information about fragrance concentrations - such as Eau de Cologne at 5%, Eau de Toilette at 10%, Eau de Parfum at 15%, and Perfume Extract at 20% - to better understand how intense and long-lasting a scent might be. Additionally, checking whether a brand follows IFRA Standards can reassure you that safety and allergenic risks are being managed responsibly.
Understanding labels is the first step to ensuring a safe and enjoyable fragrance experience.
Why Patch Testing Matters
Even with all the transparency in labeling, patch testing remains a crucial step. Ingredients - whether natural or synthetic - can still cause allergic reactions. There’s a common misconception that "natural" equals "safe", but as fragrance expert Karen Gilbert explains:
"There is a tendency to believe that natural is safer than synthetic, and as much as I would love this to be true, it’s simply not."
Natural extracts like oakmoss, jasmine, and rose often require strict safety limits because they can be highly allergenic. Even essential oils, such as Ylang Ylang, may include components like isoeugenol that are regulated for safety. A 2018 study revealed that over 75% of beauty products containing fragrances had undisclosed toxic ingredients.
Here’s where patch testing comes in. Apply a small amount of the fragrance to your inner wrist and wait 24 hours to see if there’s any redness, itching, or irritation. This simple precaution can save you from adverse reactions like dermatitis or respiratory discomfort before you commit to wearing a scent regularly.
Once you’ve identified potential allergens and conducted patch testing, sampling with Scento can help you find a fragrance that works with your unique skin chemistry. Fragrance molecules interact differently with each person, so trying a scent before committing is essential to see how it evolves from top to base notes.
Scento offers decant options in sizes like 0.75 oz, 0.07 oz, and 0.27 oz, letting you test fragrances without the financial commitment of buying a full bottle. For example, an 8 oz decant gives you about 120 sprays - plenty to evaluate a scent’s longevity, projection, and how it interacts with your skin.
While sampling, revisit the brand’s transparency policies and conduct patch tests. If you discover a fragrance that complements your body chemistry and doesn’t cause sensitivities, Scento’s future plans - such as offering larger 30 oz+ designer bottles - can help you transition from testing to curating a thoughtful, waste-free fragrance collection.
Conclusion
Transparency in fragrance is more than a buzzword - it’s a necessity. The term "fragrance" on a label can mask a cocktail of hundreds, even thousands, of chemicals. It’s important to note that neither natural nor synthetic ingredients are inherently safer. For example, natural extracts like jasmine and oakmoss often need strict safety regulations due to their high potential to cause allergies. On the other hand, synthetic ingredients can be crafted to eliminate specific irritants. As fragrance expert Karen Gilbert explains:
"There is a tendency to believe that natural is safer than synthetic, and as much as I would love this to be true, it’s simply not."
The environmental impact of fragrance ingredients adds another layer of complexity. While natural materials may seem like the eco-friendly choice, the overharvesting of resources such as Indian sandalwood highlights the need for synthetic alternatives. These lab-created ingredients help preserve endangered resources and support sustainability efforts. In fact, most modern perfumes rely on a composition of about 70% synthetic materials, which offer durability and performance that purely natural formulations often can’t achieve.
Clear labeling is a step toward accountability. Brands that adhere to IFRA Standards and disclose more than just "parfum" on their labels set a higher standard for transparency. The IFRA Transparency List, which includes thousands of disclosed ingredients, provides consumers with a clearer understanding of what they’re actually purchasing. This level of openness is essential for building trust and fostering responsible practices across the fragrance industry.
FAQs
What health risks are linked to natural and synthetic fragrance ingredients?
Both natural and synthetic fragrance ingredients can carry health risks, as a molecule’s safety is determined by its chemical structure, not its origin. Common issues include skin allergies, respiratory irritation, and hormonal disruptions. For some, exposure to certain fragrances may also trigger headaches, dizziness, or asthma-like symptoms.
Extended or high levels of exposure to specific ingredients have been linked to more serious concerns, such as reproductive and developmental problems, lowered fertility, and even cancer. Beyond personal health, some fragrance components can also negatively impact the environment, lingering in ecosystems and building up over time.
Being aware of the ingredients in your fragrances is essential for making informed decisions and minimizing risks. Clear labeling and transparency allow consumers to enjoy their favorite scents more safely.
What are the key differences between EU and U.S. regulations on fragrance ingredient transparency?
In Europe, fragrance manufacturers are held to stricter transparency standards compared to those in the U.S. They are required to disclose specific ingredients in their formulations and must list any of the 26 recognized allergens if these exceed certain concentration limits. This approach provides consumers with a clearer understanding of both natural and synthetic components in the products they use.
Meanwhile, U.S. regulations are less stringent. Fragrance ingredients can be grouped under the general label of "fragrance" or "parfum", without breaking down the individual components. Allergen disclosure is only mandated if the concentration reaches a level that could pose a safety risk. Consequently, European consumers typically receive far more detailed information about what goes into their fragrances than their American counterparts.
Why don’t brands fully disclose the ingredients in their fragrances?
Fragrance brands go to great lengths to keep their formulas under wraps, treating them as closely guarded trade secrets. Unlike other industries, perfume recipes aren’t patented, and there’s no legal obligation to list every single ingredient. This secrecy helps brands protect their creations from being copied and ensures their scents stay exclusive.
In a market where standing out is everything, this strategy is essential. However, with growing demand for transparency, the industry faces the tricky task of balancing openness with safeguarding their intellectual property.
